libarian's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Mustang Chase]

Solid

A few things: The shading makes some surfaces look a bit lumpy. Also, it doesn't really give the impression of motion, you know? It would probably be hard with a still frame like this, when you don't have soft stuff to wave around in the wind, but it just looks very static.

Randy-355 responds:

Thanks for the constructive criticism libarian, I'll keep that in mind.

[pink]

Sort of cute.

I think it would look a lot better if it was not so large, cause it looks like you are trying to do a sort of 8-bit type thing, and they generally don't look good blown up like this.

[Darth Vader]

Pretty Rad

But the pose seems kind of unnatural, mostly the positioning of his right arm, also, his right leg is notably absent.

On the other hand, the shadows and highlights are great everywhere.

[Dr. Clean]

Wat

Boy, you need some anti-aliasing. Also, the shadows on the crotch-plate are pretty rough.

Iconock responds:

EXTREEEEEEME RETRO.

[Droning About]

So good

Just could use some AA

[Tee Design 1]

Cute

But you may want to raise it up a bit. I think if it gets printed, the girl's shirt will end up having boobs halfway through the eyes.

tehslaphappy responds:

Yeah, I've been hear a lot about the eyes and boobs. Lol.

[Titanic Grand Staircase-paint-]

File Type

Seems pretty great, but when you converted the file type it kinda messed it up.

[Alex]

Paint is not your friend

Thick legs, flat feet, meaty arms, blobby teets, bug eyes, tiny mouth, and to top it off, her hair is turning away from her face. Look up some anatomy tutorials, please.

[Edwardian Portrait]

Wild

Highly kickass.

FoggyD responds:

Thanks, man :)

[Pyramid Disciple 1]

the idea of all seeing eyes.

I like it, too.